5 CHURCH STREET
PEIA · C0A1V0
$470,000
About this residence
Nestled in a charming village in southeastern PEI, this historic church has been thoughtfully transformed into 2 stunning and modern apartments. Perfect for a family with teenagers seeking independence, a combined generational family dwelling, or two separate apartments with a push-code dividing door, this property offers flexibility with modern convenience. Located just a short walk from the wharf, where you can watch the boats come and go or grab a bite at your local eatery. You are also a short drive from many beautiful beaches. There is a convenience store and a liquor outlet in the village so you'll never be without essentials, and you are only a short 20-minute drive to Montague which provides everything else you may need. Every detail in the restoration of this historic building has been carefully considered, with custom finishes and furniture that maintain its original character while adding luxury and modern amenities. Each apartment features a spacious open concept living space with a high-end custom kitchen, a seamless flow from the kitchen to the living and dining areas (perfect for entertaining), one bedroom and one custom bathroom (one with a double shower head), laundry facilities, and private entry for convenience and privacy. A push-code door allows for separate or combined living arrangements. The property also boasts a full basement under half of the building, adding more potential living space. Modern finishes blend harmoniously with the meticulously preserved original character of the church, creating a unique living experience in a serene maritime setting. Additional features include a UV light system, German electric on-demand hot water system, water softener, 2 breakfast nooks, 3 lounge/seating areas, 2 dining areas, a 400-amp electrical service, and municipal sewer. Zoned as Comm. Mixed Use, this 0.26 acre property offers endless options. Whether you're looking for a unique family home or a versatile investment, this pro (id:61366)
Property details
- Property type
- Other
- Ownership
- Freehold
- Storeys
- 1
- Living area
- 2,454 sq ft
- Lot size
- 0.26
- Year built
- 1935
- Annual tax
- $3,125
- MLS®
- 202529511
- Board
- PEIA
- Status
- Active
- Listed
- Dec 17, 2025
- Updated
- Jun 11, 2026
Features & finishes
Flooring
- Wood
Parking
- Parking Space(s)
Financing
Estimated monthly payment
$2,198/mo
Loan amount
$376,000
Down payment
$94,000
Estimate only. Rates and terms vary by lender and qualification.
Powered by Lenderoo.caLocation & area
PEIA
Nearby
About the area
Census · C0A- 48,140
- Population
- 45
- Median age
- $77,500
- Median income
- $276,000
- Median home value
- 82%
- Home ownership
- 24 min
- Avg. commute
Age distribution
Tenure
Neighbourhood statistics for the property’s forward sortation area. Figures are census-derived estimates.
Powered by Neighbourly.ioFrequently asked questions
What is the asking price for 5 CHURCH STREET?
5 CHURCH STREET is listed for $470,000, in PEIA.
What type of home is 5 CHURCH STREET?
5 CHURCH STREET is a Other set over 1 storey, built in 1935.
How large is 5 CHURCH STREET?
The home offers approximately 2,454 sq ft of living space on a lot measuring 0.26.
What would the monthly mortgage payment be?
With a 20% down payment at a 5.0% interest rate over a 25-year amortization, the estimated monthly payment is about $2,198. Use the mortgage calculator above to model your own scenario.
What are the annual property taxes?
Property taxes are approximately $3,125 per year.
What is the PEIA area like?
PEIA has a population of about 48,140, a median age of 45, a 82% home-ownership rate, with an average commute of about 24 minutes.
What is the average home value in PEIA?
The median dwelling value in this area is approximately $276,000, based on census data via Neighbourly.
What is the median household income in PEIA?
The median household income in this area is approximately $77,500.
Similar residences
Comparable homes near PEIA at a similar price.
Private viewings
Arrange a private viewing of 5 CHURCH STREET.
Our advisors offer discreet, personal guidance from first viewing through to closing. We’d be delighted to assist.



